Frank Reacts to R&A Announcement

I have read with interest the announcement by the R&A re the above subject matter and have the following comments.

First with regard to the proposed modification to the ODS (Overall Distance Standard) for golf balls; I see no difference between this and the methodology used when the standard was first adopted in 1976. The fact that Iron Byron has been given a new calibration club, ball and a higher swing speed which will increase the distance of all the test balls, the numerical limit of the standard must change from the present 291.2 yards to something approaching 305 yards if, as the R&A have indicated, no balls which presently conform will be declared non-conforming as a result of the modification to the test.

 The 'Optimum Test Procedure' proposed by the USGA and discussed in some detail with the R&A is one of the most sophisticated, relevant, scientifically sound tests in the world of sports standards but has been put on the back burner because of some concern expressed by the manufacturers.

The technology and advanced science exposed during the announcement of the Optimum Test Procedure by the USGA five years ago, has already been adopted by every major manufacturer to assist in perfecting their own ball designs, which says something for the science.

  With regard to the club head size and shaft length, the R&A have at least admitted that even though "traditional and customary" is an issue, of equal concern is the performance factor. The following is part of that statement;

"…of equal concern is the possibility that such clubs may offer undesirable performance benefits. However, the effects of increasing clubhead size in terms of performance criteria, such as driving distance and accuracy, is an area requiring further study."

And also:

"We are concerned that an increase in shaft length could increase driving distance, but we recognize that more research is needed."

 Instead of making a proposal before they are sure that there is a problem the R&A has at least indicated that they are conducting further research and getting more input from the industry before making the next move. What more can we ask?

Frankly

Frank

To read about the R&A's proposals, visit www.randa.org